Why Being Overqualified For A Job Is A Problem (Plus Other Old Guy Advice For Job Seekers)


Two women sit at a conference table. One is being interviewed for a job opening.

I saw a post on LinkedIn the other day that got under my skin a little. Not because the guy was wrong to be frustrated — he wasn’t. He’s out of work, and that’s genuinely hard. But his frustrations revealed something I keep seeing in younger professionals right now: a fundamental misunderstanding of how the job market actually works.

This young man — a surveyor, someone in my industry — had three complaints:

  1. Employers weren’t responding to his applications with personalized feedback.
  2. Companies kept telling him he was “overqualified,” which made no sense to him.
  3. Jobs advertised as “hybrid” only let him work from home one or two days a week.

I want to address all three of these. Not to be controversial or to pile on someone who’s already struggling. I’m doing this because I hire people like him, and I genuinely want to help younger professionals adjust to a reality that’s shifted beneath their feet.

Here’s the hard truth: what you experienced the last five years was not a normal job market.


The Pendulum Has Swung

Since around 2020, we’ve been in a job market that strongly favored employees. Salaries climbed. Remote work became the default. Companies bent over backwards to attract and retain talent. If you started your career during this window, you might think that’s just how things work.

It’s not.

Job markets are cyclical. They swing between favoring employers and favoring employees. For the last several years, the pendulum was way over on the employee side. Now it’s swinging back toward center — and it may overcorrect, as these things often do.

This isn’t a “bad” job market yet. I’ve seen bad job markets. I graduated into one. We’re not there. But we’re not in 2021 anymore either.


What a Bad Job Market Actually Looks Like

I’m going to say something that might sound controversial: we haven’t had a truly bad job market for employees since somewhere around 2008 to 2010. That was fifteen years ago. Which means there’s a huge generation of workers — anyone under 35 or so — who has never experienced what a bad job market really feels like.

I think that’s part of where the entitlement comes from. Not malice, not selfishness — just inexperience.

So let me paint the picture for those who haven’t lived through it.

A bad job market isn’t when you’ve been unemployed for four months and can’t find the job you want. That’s a slightly loose job market. That’s what we have now.

A bad job market is when you can’t get any job. When you’re a CAD drafter with eight years of experience or a GIS analyst with a decade under your belt and a bachelor’s degree, and you can’t get hired as a cashier at Walmart or a night shift manager at Wendy’s. Not just “can’t find work in my field” — can’t find work, period.

I’ve lived through that three times. Late 90s, early 2000s, and the Great Recession around 2010. So has everyone else over 40. And those experiences recalibrate your expectations. They make you hungry. They teach you to stand out from your competition. They discipline your money habits — you save more, you’re careful about debt, you don’t assume the good times will last forever.

Here’s what happens in a truly bad job market: people have cars repossessed. They foreclose on credit card debt and file bankruptcy. They lose their homes. Household formation collapses — people move back in with parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles. Good workers, good people, good human beings can’t find work because of circumstances completely outside their control.

I remember 2010. Four out of five families I knew were foreclosing on their homes. That’s real human suffering at scale.

We’re not there yet. We’re not even close.

So if you’re out of work right now and you feel like the universe is punishing you, like you’re experiencing some grave injustice — I’m going to be honest with you. You’re wrong. We’re nowhere near grave injustice yet. The economy may steady out and we may never get there. I hope we don’t. I hope I never see that kind of suffering again in my lifetime.

But if you’re a young professional frustrated about a four-month job search? You ain’t seen nothing yet.


Why Nobody’s Responding to Your Application

Let me explain something from the employer’s side of the table.

When I post a job opening — something entry-level, maybe $25-30 an hour — I’ll get 100 applicants within 48 hours. Probably more now. And here’s the thing: the vast majority of those applications aren’t even close to qualified. People are blasting resumes everywhere, sometimes using AI tools to auto-apply to hundreds of jobs at once.

I physically cannot send a personalized response to every applicant. I don’t have time to craft a thoughtful email to someone halfway across the country who didn’t read the job description, isn’t qualified, and clearly applied to my posting as one of fifty that day.

Is that frustrating for job seekers? Absolutely. But it’s a consequence of how technology has changed the application process. When applying takes thirty seconds, everyone applies to everything, and employers drown in volume.

Now, here’s where I’ll draw a line: if a company brings you in for an interview — an actual conversation with a human being — they owe you a response. A phone call, an email, something. That’s basic professional courtesy, and my company always follows up with candidates we’ve interviewed. But responding to every cold application? That’s just not realistic anymore.


The Real Reason “Overqualified” Is a Problem

This one confused the guy in the LinkedIn post. “If I’m overqualified,” he wrote, “why wouldn’t you want to hire me?”

It actually makes perfect sense once you understand what employers are really evaluating.

When I’m considering a candidate, I’m not just thinking about their skills or what I’d have to pay them. I’m thinking about their flight risk — how likely they are to leave when something better comes along.

Here’s what experience has taught me: when you hire someone overqualified, it might work out great in the short term. You’re getting above-market skills for below-market pay. But as soon as the economy improves or a better opportunity appears, that person is gone. And I don’t blame them — they should go get their market wage. But I also can’t ignore that reality when I’m hiring.

This matters because I’m not running an Amazon warehouse. There’s an enormous amount of what we call “firm-specific knowledge” that every new hire has to absorb — my systems, my processes, my client relationships, my company culture. That onboarding takes months, and it costs real money. Employee turnover is an insidious, radioactive poison for professional services businesses.

So when I see an overqualified candidate, I see someone who’s going to absorb all that investment and then leave the moment something better materializes. I’d much rather hire someone who matches the job requirements — or is even slightly underqualified and can grow into the role — because they’re far more likely to stick around.

What does this mean for you? Stop applying for jobs you’re overqualified for. You’re more likely to land something that matches your experience level, or even something that’s a stretch. Counterintuitive, but true.

The painful reality is that when job markets soften, companies cut middle management first. A lot of professionals find themselves in an awkward gap — overqualified for the jobs that actually move the needle on production, but underqualified for executive roles. That’s a tough spot, and I don’t have an easy answer for it. But understanding why “overqualified” is a red flag might at least help you stop spinning your wheels.


One Day a Week From Home Is Not “Hybrid”

I’m going to be more blunt on this one.

News flash for everyone under 40: working from home one or two days a week is hybrid. That’s what hybrid means.

Working from home 19 days a month and showing up at the office once? That’s not hybrid. That’s full-time remote with occasional appearances.

During COVID and the years that followed, a lot of people got very comfortable working from home in their pajamas. I understand why they liked it. It’s more comfortable for the employee. But here’s what we’ve learned as employers: there are significant costs to fully remote work, especially for younger professionals who benefit enormously from absorbing company culture and being mentored by experienced colleagues.

Companies like mine are much less willing to hire fully remote people now, and I don’t see that changing. We’re probably never going back to the pre-COVID world of mandatory five-days-a-week office time. But the pendulum is swinging back toward more in-office work, and as the job market loosens, employers will have the leverage to demand it.

This isn’t just about what’s good for the business. In my experience, more time in the office is usually better for young professionals too — maybe not in the short term, but definitely in the long term.


A Word About LinkedIn Rants

One more piece of advice, and this one might sting a little.

Be very careful how you express job search frustration on LinkedIn. Potential employers see that content. And when someone’s feed is full of posts about how unfair the universe is, how businesses are predatory, how employers are taking advantage of vulnerable job seekers — that’s a massive red flag.

It tells me you might be a problem employee. It suggests character traits I don’t want on my team. Rightly or wrongly, that content will eliminate you from consideration at a lot of professional firms.

There’s a difference between posting “Here’s my situation — I’m struggling to find work. What advice do you have?” and posting “I don’t know what’s wrong with all these horrible businesses. I’m wonderful. Why won’t anyone hire me?”

The first one is fine. Maybe even helpful. The second one is career poison.

Want to vent? Do it on Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, whatever. Not on LinkedIn. It’s the wrong platform for that.


The Point of All This

I’m not saying any of this because I enjoy watching people struggle. I want to see young professionals succeed. But there’s a serious mismatch right now between expectations and reality, and that mismatch is hurting people’s job searches.

Employers respond to economic incentives, just like employees do. This is a cycle. The job market will favor employees again — probably within the next five to ten years. But that’s not where the cycle is headed right now.

Denying that reality, getting upset about it, throwing a temper tantrum on social media — none of that will help you find a job.

What will help? Adjust your expectations. Manage your money better. Invest in your skills. Network professionally. And understand that the last five years were the anomaly, not the norm.

The market isn’t broken. It’s just not bending in your direction anymore.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *